I never compare RWCL to the two Marvin, Welch & Farrar vocal albums
M,W, & F were a vocal group in the same league as say CSN (& Y), America, Bread, The Eagles etc....& the short lived Mike Rickfors fronted Hollies (of the same 1972-73 period)
those groups each had an acoustic/electric instrumental sound but with firm emphasis on harmony vocals with various members featured as Lead vocalists in a more 'west coast' style of seventies singer/songwriters banded together as a group...
it's notable the M, W, & F first album was more acoustic based (tho' not exclusively) than 'Second Opinion' too but neither were in the style of The Shadows - 'You're Burning Bridges', 'Simplfy Your Head','Throw Down A Line, 'Black Eyes', 'Let's Say Goodbye' etc are nothing like The Shadows style (even tho' later admittedly 'It'll Be Me Babe' wasn't either in 1976 !)
interesting to compare the M,W, & F single studio version of 'Marmaduke' to The Shads 'Live in Paris' version....despite identical or near identical line ups & vocalists note how the STYLES are quite different with The Shads take being the more instantly commercial featuring Hank's characteristic guitar licks and some Marvin/Farrar harmony guitarwork, while M W & F have a 'folkier' more acoustic based feel to their single version...
I'd like to see the instrumentals from 'Specs Appeal' and the John Farrar featured instrumentals from 'Tasty' compiled as the originally intended all instrumental album follow up to RWCL - with the mono single version of 'God Only Knows', plus instrumental 'No No Nina', and 'The Air That I Breathe' added as 'bonus tracks' - such a compilation would make for a fine 'lost' instrumental Shadows album from the mid seventies...
I've heard Sir Paul McCartney once offered 'Here, There, & Everywhere' to The Shads as a possible instrumental (?) - that would sound great if Hank (with Ben) cut it now....


