by ash » 29 Nov 2013, 17:53
Personally i think Jimi was brilliant. Those first 3 Experience albums and the non-lp singles are essential. There are dozens of fantastic live performances "out there" too. Comparing Jimi and Hank is a waste of time. They both played a Strat and that's about it. Jimi didn't wear glasses.
They both bought something new and exciting to guitar playing and continue to be influential. It's not fair to blame Jimi for the wave of crap twiddly speed merchants that followed anymore than it is fair to blame John Coltrane for every sax player riffing endlessly through scales in the name of jazz.
Hendrix was a very good composer, heavily influenced by Dylan. Vocally he's not great but more tuneful than his royal Bobness. He's not just a noise merchant guitar-wise. Castles Made Of Sand, One Rainy Wish spring to mind and side 3 of Electric Ladyland is a masterful sound painting. He's also pretty mean on an acoustic guitar (seek and ye shall find). Third Stone From The Sun is quite Wes Montgomery-influenced.
He did get trapped by the early "tricks" but he knew that and was frustrated by it. He didn't actually burn and smash guitars that often, it's been blown out of proportion. Sometimes he did just hammer on/off instead of playing with his teeth, sometimes he really did play with his teeth - so what.
His complete performance at Monterey is a masterclass of electric guitar playing. I wish i could have been there.
Some performances of Machine Gun are as powerful a statement as Alabama by John Coltrane if more confrontational and a bit louder !
He's admired by people such as Peter Green, Jeff Beck etc. who all also deeply admire Hank.
I would however argue that lack of discipline (studio-wise) exacerbated by the lack of input from Chas Chandler meant that he spent most of 1969 and 1970 recording rather repetitive, similar sounding tracks that weren't of the same standard recorded from 1966 to 1968. At least he was trying to move forward and significantly alter his style which i often feel Hank and The Shads completely gave up doing far too early in their career's.
I could have waffled on less...bottom line - Hank is brilliant, Jimi is brilliant and i wish i could play half as well as either of them. We should be really grateful for the awesome music they made. We are very lucky.