by stratmantd » 07 Apr 2013, 10:31
fenderman & hankb56,
I didn't say that TFYL wasn't a true Shadows number. I happen to think that it is a great representation of the Shads composition and playing.
I said that "some people on this site probably don't consider TFYL a true Shadows number because Jet and Tony weren't on it". I did not say that that was my opinion and don't believe that I implied it either. However, going by some of the threads over the years it is patently obvious that there are a significant number of people on here who think that the first line-up was the be-all and end-all and nothing was the same afterwards. Thank goodness for change. The guys had to change "that sound", whichever one it was as not only the music changed but their abilities as musicians.
It is far easier for a radio station to interrupt an instrumental than a song with vocals. It could be that a disproportionally high number of Shadows numbers are cut this way because of their higher success rate with instrumentals than anyone else.