Tab wrote:9s for Shads stuff? Don't think so!
Why So?
I've got various guitars with 9's 10's and 11's on, Fender, Burns, Parker etc and there's more difference in the sound one guitar to another than there is if I change string guage.
I picked up an interesting youtube A/B string comparison on two strat one with 9's the other with either 10's or 11's the general conclusion was that there wasn't a huge amount of difference.
With lighter strings you can have a lower action and that will effect the sound as well, but for me, body timber, pickups, amps and the speakers you choose have far more effect on sound than string guage.
You have to play a bit more carefully with 9's on because the lighter guage is likely to get pushed sharp more easily.
For the absolute purist I guess if you have the correct guitar for each tune played through the same amp and echo as at the time then string guage completes the picture, but of course what you can never re-create is the sound of a young mans fingers on the fret board and pick when you're a touch super annuated!